Lower Lafitte, Louisiana — Blades of grass are beginning to pass thick swamp dust in Russell Rodriguez’s backyard as the mid-October sun hits southeast Louisiana.
A bald eagle hovers over tall trees and morning rays shine over the undulating waters of nearby Barataria Bayou as it heads into the Gulf of Mexico.
It would be an idyllic widespread destruction.
Houses are destroyed, ripped from their pylons and broken, fishing boats are dumped ashore, coffins carried through local cemeteries are open, bones are still waiting to be claimed.
That’s more than Rodriguez can bear. After decades in Lower Lafitte, about 65 miles south of New Orleans, he and his wife are leaving their home and their United Houma Nation neighbors for higher ground.
“This is a life-changing event,” said Rodriguez, a citizen of Houma. “I don’t like the concept of having to leave but I don’t want to weather another storm. Climate change is the cause. People who deny it. I want a science lesson.
Rodriguez is among tens of thousands of tribal citizens across the Indian country who are forced to decide between staying on their ancestral lands or moving to themselves due to the devastation caused by climate change.
Indigenous peoples along the coastal spaces and waterways of the United States, from Alaska to Florida and from California to Maine, face flooding, rising sea levels, coastal erosion, and severe hurricanes. Those in the southwest and plains have been hit by an unprecedented drought. forest fires, heat, reduced water tables and depleted waterways. They all face habitat loss and the reduction of classic food resources for people, livestock and wildlife.
And migration has already begun, and at least some of a dozen tribal communities have had to officially settle on high ground. For others, outward migration is more subtle, unfolding quietly and without fanfare as climate realities replace success in indigenous homes and livelihoods. Indian Country Today revealed in an informal survey of tribal nations in the United States.
The effect on indigenous cultures, histories and languages is immeasurable.
In the Houma Nation, elders who cannot bear the emotional or monetary burden of rebuilding are among the highs likely to move, creating a void that cannot be filled, houma leader August “Cocoa” Creppel said.
“It’s very difficult,” Creppel said. This is where they were born and raised, that’s where their parents, our grandparents, were. It makes us lose our way of life, in the swamp.
“It’s watching older people walk away. “
The Houma Nation has no official tribal territories, yet its 19,000 citizens are concentrated in southeast Louisiana in six parishes, most of louisiana’s counties. Most live in the vicinity of the towns of Dulac, Jean Lafitte and Houma, named in the 1830s for the tribe.
Nearly 11,000 Houma Nationals were injured when Hurricane Ida landed near Port Fourchon, Louisiana, on Aug. 29, 16 years after the day Hurricane Katrina hit the Louisiana coast, Creppel said.
It is one of the worst typhoons ever recorded in the U. S. USA And the worst to hit Louisiana, surpassing Katrina with winds of 150 mph, a typhoon storm surge of 12 to 14 feet and more than 15 inches of rain in some areas.
More than six weeks after Ida’s passage, reconstruction noises can be heard among the rubble, but many homes are too destroyed to be recovered.
Rodriguez’s space is among those that have been closed, with a motorboat trimmed in dust drying under the dented garage. He and his wife, Judith, bought the space in 1995 and lifted it on stilts more than 8 feet above the floor. after Katrina flooded the domain in 2005.
However, space took more than two feet of water from Hurricane Ida and is now a few feet above the layers of dust the storm brought. Still without electricity.
Rodriguez, 73, and his wife, who is a few years older, fled before the typhoon hit and spent weeks living miles away, first with their circle of relatives and then in motels, and return periodically to see the damage.
“It’s a long journey,” he says. I’m just not going to face the warmth as well as I used to. “
The Houma domain faces the same disorders that have wreaked havoc on other communities in southern Louisiana. Barrier islands that once slowed down storms as they moved toward the coast are disappearing, victims of erosion and rising sea point. Artificial canals in swamp pastures supply access. for oil personnel, it still allows the gulf’s salt water to grow further inland and with greater force. The rains are now torrential.
Citizens of other Louisiana tribes are also moving. Southeast of Houma, the Strip of Jean Charles Island of the Biloxi-Chitimacha-Choctaw Indian Tribe has been hit several times by hurricanes and has suffered some other blow from Hurricane Ida. Tribal citizens have lived for generations on the narrow island in the swamp of the parish of Terrebonne.
The Jean Charles Island Band joined the Houma Nation in proposing resettlement off the island, the destruction posed an existential risk to their communities and culture. Since 1955, Jean Charles Island has lost 98% of its land mass and at least 75% of its inhabitants. , according to a 2020 report through the Government Accountability Office.
The state, with federal funds, purchased 515 acres in Shriever, Louisiana, about 40 miles north of the mainland, to relocate tribal citizens. Between 15 and 20 houses have been structured lately and 39 families are expected to move in during the spring, Chief Albert Naquin said. Indian country today.
Citizens of the Indian tribe closest to Pointe-au-Chien, who live along a swamp of the same name, were also destroyed through Ida, such as Grand Isle, a barrier island that continually lashed storms. also contemplating moving.
However, some tribal citizens are waiting to take the plunge.
Naquin said he left Jean Charles Island for the next city after Hurricane Carmen in 1974 because he may no longer go to work. Many are now packing their bags and leaving their houses in ruins after Ida.
“People left by force or by choice,” Naquin said.
Nearly 5,000 miles south of Louisiana, weather is destroying the Yup’ik village of Newtok in southwest Alaska.
Newtok once sat on the top floor, from typhoons through the sea ice. The frozen floor, the permafrost, stood firm. Now the ground is melting and collapsing, and the action of waves and typhoons are sweeping away. The village has already lost a mile of land due to erosion. Barges can no longer land and the river approaches the runway which is used by small planes to take inventory. until.
The village lies between two rivers, the Newtok and the Ninglik, near its access point to the Bering Sea. The village has been flooded several times over the past decade, and in September 2005, an autumn typhoon caused flooding to surround the village. everywhere, turning it into an island.
Erosion in 2021 has been bad, as the crusmerized coastline has brought the river even closer to the community, tribal administrator Phillip Carl said.
“We had to lose. . . probably about a hundred feet,” Carl said. The school’s water plant is the closest to erosion. This will need to be about 190 feet (from the existing coastline).
Carl said the village had still faced strong winds this fall, but they are expected to arrive soon.
“There’s an electric pole that’s about to fall,” he said. The space served through the electric pole will be abandoned.
Alaska is one of the states hardest hit by climate change, with at least 31 Indigenous communities threatened with destruction over the next 25 years due to flooding and erosion, according to tests conducted by the U. S. Army Corps of Engineers. USA And the GAO.
Newtok is one of 4 Alaska Native villages known to be in danger of “imminent destruction,” meaning they are expected to be uninhabitable for the next five years, according to government reports.
Of the 4, Newtok, Kivalina, Shishmaref and Shaktoolik, Newtok has made really considerable progress in relocating its residents.
Newtok began making plans to move in the 1990s, getting small scholarships here and there for his studies. He chose a site and negotiated a land change with the U. S. Fish and Wildlife Service. USA Which was approved by Congress in 2003.
The exchange allows for the eventual relocation of the village’s approximately 350 inhabitants to Mertarvik, which means “fresh water,” a site on Nelson Island about 15 km or 25 minutes by boat. Mertarvik is situated in the classic lands of the tribe and supplies subsistence resources. It is also resistant to erosion.
As of December 2019, the structure of a quarry, landfill, contact stage, transitory airstrip, roads, power plant, fuel storage, water and wastewater recovery plants and 21 houses were completed, the GAO reported.
At least 135 other people have already made the journey and the rest were forced to stay until more houses were built.
Other threatened Alaskan villages are also moving. Approximately 370 miles north of Newtok in the village of Shishmaref in Inupiat, citizens voted in 2016 to move their network due to erosion and flooding attributed to climate change.
Shishmaref is located on Sarichef Island, a quarter-mile-wide and three-mile-long barrier island in the Chukchi Sea, just outside the Arctic Circle.
State and federal agencies have spent about $25 million since 2004 to make a larger levee in an effort to contain the sea, yet Shishmaref continues to lose about 3 to five feet of coastline due to erosion each year, according to a report through the nonprofit Climate Adaptation Knowledge Exchange. Several houses and the National Guard Armory have already moved inland due to erosion.
It will be a painful gesture. The Inupiados have lived on the island for at least 4,000 years and the remains of their ancestors are buried there in a cemetery. Resettlement is being planned and prices have not yet been determined, according to Shishmaref’s Strategic Management Plan.
About 35 miles east of Newtok, the Yup’ik village of Akiak struggles with erosion. The tribe recently moved six mined houses across the Kuskokwim River, said Michael Williams Sr. , leader of the Akiak Indigenous Community.
“We’re comparing a few more houses and structures, and if they’re within sixty meters of the river, we have to move them,” Williams said.
“The permafrost is receding and getting thinner and thinner,” he said. “Our returns from Chinook have been low and our boyfriend has not returned this year. Over the past five or ten years, we have experienced genuine hot summers, a lack of rain, a lack of snow upstream, and a lack of ice. The thickness of the ice (of the river) should be about two meters. That’s less than a meter.
Warmer temperatures meant water. Dead fish have been discovered in the Tanana River and adjustments in caribou migration provide new demanding situations for subsistence hunters, he said.
Williams, 69, said the ones he saw are all new, unknown to his grandparents and great-grandparents.
“The warming is huge,” he said.
In the Inupiat village north of Kivalina, the network voted to leave the barrier island where it now stands in the Chukchi Sea, 83 miles from the Arctic Circle.
However, the government has not yet been able to locate a suitable site with smart hunting, fishing and water, a site selected in 2000 that the Army Corps of Engineers deemed too threatened by the adverse effects of climate change.
The relocation of the entire network will not be successful in the coming years, so citizens are looking to adapt, said tribal administrator Millie Hawley.
An evacuation address ended in November 2020, and a school and network center will reach the mainland near the village.
“We have to do it with what we have,” he said. Where are we going?We are on an island. The nearest village is 70 miles away.
There is a sense of urgency in the Quinault Nation of Taholah in northwestern Washington state.
Taholah flooded in January 2021 when the ocean broke through a levee, and models prepared by the state Department of Natural Resources show the network in danger of a possible tsunami 40 to 50 feet deep. they are expected to increase more than 2. 5 feet to 2100.
Construction is underway to build a new upper village at an altitude above about a mile from the center of the existing village, beyond the expected success of rising seas and tsunamis.
Quinault expects his new village to be completed by 2030, with various types of housing, a K-12 school, a park, trails, a networking center and offices for tribal government and emergency services. in early 2022.
Infrastructure prices, for communications, roads and utilities, are estimated at more than $50 million.
A recently outstanding bill in Congress would give a contribution of about $500,000 to help the tribe’s canopy infrastructure costs. The bill also includes approximately $1. 5 million in investment for the Quileute Tribe in La Push, Washington.
The Quileutes have also experienced heavy flooding, rising sea points and erosion, and run an increased tsunami threat. The tribe has to move to the top floor about 4 miles away, and the structure of a new school is underway.
Still, some will remain in the dying village, where the other Quileute caught fish and shellfish and hunted on Washington’s northwest coast for centuries.
Other tribes in the western and northwestern United States are also affected by climate change, but have yet to make a resolution to relocate tribal operations. However, no one knows how many citizens were going to retreat discreetly to spaces less threatened by the devastation.
In Oregon and Idaho, the tribal nations that make up the Upper Snake River Tribes Foundation — Burns Paiute Tribe, Fort McDermitt Paiute and Shoshone Tribes, Shoshone-Bannock Tribes of Fort Hall and Shoshone-Paiute Tribes of Duck Valley — have documented adjustments in species and habitats driven by emerging temperatures and the conversion of rainfall patterns.
In northeastern Oregon, Confederate tribes on the Umatilla Indian Reservation report that the country, what they call the first, is affected by rising temperatures.
In Montana, 3 tribes regrouped in August to save homes, lives and cultural sites when wildfires sparked by hot and dry situations burned nearly 200,000 acres. Reserve were evacuated.
And in California’s Kern Valley, heat and drought are affecting the Tubatulabal tribe’s access to classic foods, as well as their overall quality of life. The smoke-laden air this year from fires in the drought-slippery region, tribal President Robert Gomez said.
“We had chimney place after chimney place and the smoke was terrible,” he said. “We had 67 days with temperatures above one hundred degrees in the county. “
Vernon Masayesva, an elderly Hopi woman, did not have to miss the last katsina dance last July, when tribal lands were “dry” amid an unprecedented drought. The ceremonial dance brings prayers for the rain.
“He’s very much in our community,” he said. I sought to hear the supreme prayer.
However, just before the dance began, a deluge broke out, torrential rains created rivers in the streets, and the village became a lake, and some houses in low spaces were flooded.
“There’s a big storm,” he says. A downpour. I had never noticed anything like it. “
Masayesva had to leave before the floods worsened, but her daughters were left waiting. The clouds separated just in time for the last dance. The rains had stopped.
It was a non-secular time for many, even if the unforeseen rains meant other things to other people. For some, they were a blessing, a sign that prayers for rain had been answered; for others, they served as a warning that Hopis and others will have to replace their habits.
“You can take it any way,” he said. This is the theme of the ceremony, of the rain. (But) it is a sign from Mother Earth that humanity desires to establish itself. It’s an unbalanced world.
Water is at the center of climate change in the southwestern United States, where the Hopi, Navajo, Pueblo and other tribes have lived for generations. Water and rain are scarce, causing corn to die in the fields, forcing sheep and foresaying for food. and drinks, and forcing families to queue for water for their homes.
The smell of smoke from forest fires caused by hot and dry situations is all too familiar to the region’s indigenous peoples.
Sometimes drought is followed by torrential rains before the dry heat takes over local indigenous communities and affects their families, cultures and traditions.
Masayesva, former president of the Hopi tribe, is from the village of Hotevilla and said he was unaware that tribal citizens are migrating from their homeland due to climate change and that they have left for decades for other reasons.
“There are many Hopi families who have left long before this climate situation,” he said. “These are the other people who looked for well-paying jobs. There are none on the floor. They looked for their young people. “to move on to the most productive schools. Our schools are in very poor condition. For those kinds of reasons, many left a long time behind.
But they don’t stay away for long, he said.
“They are leaving permanently,” he said. They have extended family homes Ceremony, brings them all back.
The Seminole Tribe of Florida is one of dozens of tribes in the southeastern United States and the East Coast that are the devastating effects of climate change.
Increasingly strong hurricanes, emerging sea degrees, and heat-related erosion and periodic droughts threaten the Seminole lands that have sustained their other people for centuries.
“The Seminoles’ home in the lower Everglades is seriously threatened by climate change,” according to a recent report on the near disintegration of historic Egmont Key, an island off the coast of Tampa Bay where the Seminoles have been temporarily locked up. while waiting to be sent west.
The Seminole Tribe, which oversees six tribal territories with approximately 5,000 inhabitants, stretches from South Florida north to the Florida Everglades and spaces near Lake Okeechobee.
The tribe, which owns a restaurant and hotel empire that includes Hard Rock and Seminole games, recently hired its first climate resilience manager, Jill Horwitz, to create a local program that combines classical wisdom with science. to draft a climate replacement reaction plan.
“Climate change affects us all, and we have a role,” Horwitz said.
Horwitz said tribal lands, which are already prone to hurricanes and other storms, have undergone adjustments between droughts and floods in recent years, but he is unaware of citizens having to leave the region due to climate change.
“There are no citizens moving because of the rising sea level,” he said.
Other tribes in the southeastern United States are feeling the effects. The Lumbee Tribe of North Carolina, which has a long history with the Lumbee River and the coastal plains of the highlands, is facing an unprecedented increase in flooding and hurricanes.
The state-recognized tribe, with about 60,000 citizens, is the largest in the eastern United States, and most of its tribal citizens live in or near the Lumbee River basin, according to a 2018 study on the effect of climate change. on the Lumbee through Dr. Ryan E. Emanuel, a citizen of Lumbee and a professor at North Carolina State University, will move next year to Duke University’s Nicholas School of the Environment in Durham.
The tribe has no tribal lands, thousands of citizens own land in the basin.
“The Lumbee tribe has strong historical, cultural, and socioeconomic ties to the Lumbee River, and climate replacement has the potential to adjust hydrological and ecological situations along the river, through its connected wetlands, and in its watershed in a way that has serious implications for the tribe,” Emanuel concluded in the study. which was published in the Journal of Contemporary Water Research.
The effect will be felt in hunting, fishing, gathering, basketry, pottery, medicinal plants and religion.
“We appreciate those swamps and we appreciate those wetlands,” Emanuel told Indian Country Today. “Floods prevent us from staying in our waters. Our ancestors fished, sailed, depended much more on water than we do now. . . ) suffering to unite with rivers and swamps.
Migration is slow as other people leave flood-prone areas, with some homeowners being bought into their homes after Hurricanes Matthew and Florence in 2016 and 2018, he said, while others quietly do so on their own.
“I don’t see evidence of large-scale migrations from Lumbee outside of our home countries, and that’s because the floods, while traumatic in recent years, are localized,” he said. the accidental movements of other people living in the tight spaces move towards the upper ground. “
Emanuel grew up in Charlotte, North Carolina, but his parents grew up in Robeson County, in the center of lumbee Country. His circle of relatives has close ties to the region.
“My grandmother, aunts, uncles, cousins, they all lived in the Lumbee community,” she said.
However, climate change is looming. The Lumbee tribe recently approved a solution that called for studies on flooding and its effects on tribal lands, he said.
“The tribal council approving this solution means it is in a position to take a more proactive stance,” he said. “It signals to me that they are starting to look to the future. “
Back in Louisiana, jars of peanut butter and canned goods are stacked along the hallways of United Houma Nation’s new tribal administration building, while staff citizens take inventory and order Array.
The building, a former retirement home recently donated to the tribe, will be renovated for new use this summer when the typhoon hit. The new plaster board is now torn off and the internal walls are usually bare up to the poles. , however, unlike many of its citizens.
Renovation plans can simply be changed to allow the construction to serve as a shelter for citizens in the next storm, tribal administrator Lanor Curole said. A backup generator is also added to the plan.
Creppel, the chief of Houma, said he was running to supply in all mandatory capacities: tribal citizens who stay, those who leave and those who have not made a decision.
“The hardest thing to be a leader: 11,000 of my other relatives were affected by the hurricane and in just a few hours, their lives changed,” he said. “People ask, ‘Why are you all staying there?’If it hadn’t been for hurricane season, it would be paradise. “
The Houma Nation is the largest tribe identified throughout the state of Louisiana, but without federal recognition, it is eligible for safe federal funds for crisis relief. This is a sensitive issue, and the tribe is fighting for federal recognition.
Creppel said other people can’t move, others can’t rebuild. Many tribal citizens live off the water and have lost their homes and boats. Those who can still fish have nowhere to sell their catches, as local seafood vendors have also been overcome through the storm.
“People heal physically but emotionally,” he said.
At the tribe’s headquarters, Councilwoman Louise Billiot, a citizen of Houma, is helping citizens apply before taking a guest for a walk in the swamp south of Houma in Dulac, where he grew up.
He saw climate migration with his own eyes. After Hurricanes Katrina and Gustav, many citizens fled from Dulac to the Ashland area, where a gigantic network of cell homes with housing for more than a hundred families was born.
Many of those houses were destroyed in Ida, leaving citizens to retreat to move.
“We had a big migration after Katrina and Gustav,” Billiot said. “Now, this has just devastated this community.
“It wasn’t superior enough. “
The effect on the tribe has been devastating, he said.
“Years ago, we were a community, a close-knit tribal community,” he said. “What happened, with time and the devastation of the hurricanes, is that we were moved. We don’t practice our culture as much. We don’t mean indigenity, but we lose a lot. “
In the declining component of Lafitte, the nonprofit United Friendship set up a tent to distribute bottled food and iced tea, paper and other supplies.
Gregory Creppel, a Houma citizen and cousin of the chief, and his wife, Lisa, created the arrangement to serve the community. They set up the tent in Lower Lafitte because no one else was offering assistance in the area, he said.
The tent is a short walk from a net cemetery that hit through the storm. Some of the coffins fell from their crypts, capsized and split in the flood waters. The same swamp dust that Gregory Creppel’s grandmother used to mold into clay kilns now covers them all. .
Gretchen Billiot Boudreaux, the tribal council member representing the area, is helping distribute supplies and understands what many citizens are facing.
“Half of the other people can’t go back,” he said. “They ask themselves: what else am I doing?Now our young people do not know the history that those elders have just taught them.
A Red Cross van pointed to a square near the United Friendship tent to distribute homemade jambalaya meals. A scarce but steady stream of citizens settles in for a hot meal.
Rodriguez and his wife, however, are not among them; now they’re looking for housing closer to New Orleans, either a protective levee or at a height high enough that they don’t want it.
“It’s a difficult resolution to make,” Rodriguez said. “But it will have to be like this. These are diminishing returns. “
However, everyone at Lower Lafitte packs their bags to leave.
Giovanni R. ” Jay” Santini, the oldest citizen of the Houma Nation in the region, said he would leave the swampy lands where he lived for up to 86 years. He grew up there and his mom taught him classic methods, adding to make huts out of saw palmetto leaves.
He fished, drove boats, was a carpenter and lived off the land.
“I’ve made my total life here,” he told Indian Country Today. “I used to hunt alligators. We caught the muskrat. Fish, catfish. I collected black moss and green moss to make a living. I fished for a living. ” There’s nothing I haven’t done.
His sturdy, bright blue house, built with his own hands about 50 years ago, dominates many other people in the neighborhood. He suffered injuries five times greater than a year’s and built his home more than 10 feet after Hurricane Rita in 2005.
This time, with Ida, her space didn’t drink water but had damage to the roof that allowed water to enter some rooms. However, the electric power is still working, which means air conditioning, and a blue tar tarr covers the damaged sections of the roof.
For now, he is fighting with government officials to get dust out of the ditch along the street so that winter rains evacuate properly. A signal displayed on the most sensitive of its front stairs sends the message.
“86 years,” it reads. I seem to have 2 digging my trench. HELP. “
But he and others are threatened with ruin. Some citizens are focusing on restoring their overturned boats before they can make their homes livable again.
“It hurts,” he says. It pains me to see all the spaces that are absolutely destroyed, people have nothing to start with. At least I blessed, I have a space with 4 walls and a ceiling. I have something to go back to. Some other people have nothing at all.
“Only in the position will it make you cry,” he said.
He knows that the loss of tribal citizens in the community, especially the elderly, can cripple cultural and ancient ties with the land for others, but he understands why some can’t return.
“I’m sorry for them,” he said. I know they love the position here. “
To learn more about United Houma Nation, visit the tribal page online or Facebook page. Information about the non-profit United Friendship can be obtained on their Facebook page.
Contributors to this story for Indian Country Today also come with Carina Dominguez, Mary Annette Pember and Sandra Hale Schulman.
Dianna Hunt of Cherokee Nation is the editor-in-chief of Indian Country Today. She can be reached at [email protected] or on Twitter: @DiannaHunt.
Joaqlin Estus is a longtime journalist in Anchorage, Alaska.
Richard Arlin Walker, Mexican/Yaqui, lives in the Samish of Anacortes, Washington, about 80 miles northwest of Seattle.
Get daily news, detailed reports, and critical research from journalists, activists, and thinkers rushing into our world.